LMD Rankings review · 2026

How our Week 9 rankings did

2026 season · Half PPR · Board published November 5, before kickoff

View the Week 9 rankings

LMD vs. Expert Consensus vs. the previous-week results baseline

LMD vs. Expert Consensus vs. the previous-week results baseline
Week 9 Half PPRLMDExpert ConsensusPrevious-week results baseline
Start/sit calls correct 67% 71% 53%
QB 72% 71% 47%
RB 62% 69% 59%
WR 68% 72% 51%
TE 78% 74% 43%
Starter picks correct 51% 50% 42%
Typical rank miss 9 spots 10 spots 12 spots
Average rank miss 12.5 13.2 21.1

On the same 2,080 start/sit pairs, LMD put the higher scorer first 67.3% of the time, Expert Consensus 71.0% and the previous-week results baseline 52.6%. The previous-week results baseline ranks each position by the points players scored in Week 8, with no model and no adjustment, and grades that order on Week 9. It is not LMD's Week 8 rankings or the Week 8 review's figures. DeVonta Smith (WR11), Garrett Wilson (WR17) and Mike Evans (WR22) were ruled out after the board's cutoff and still count as misses in every figure here.

Both lists were published before the review's cutoff. The Expert Consensus list was published about four hours before LMD's board (November 5, 18:08 UTC) and may not reflect updates during that interval. Every section below grades LMD's whole board. One week is a small sample.

Expert Consensus: Half PPR lists for QB, RB, WR and TE, published November 5, 14:01 UTC. Expert Consensus source: borischen.co.

Top finish picks

Top finish picks
LMDExpert ConsensusPrevious-week results baseline
Top 3 picks correct 42% 50% 17%
Top 12 picks correct 52% 50% 38%
Top 24 picks correct 59% 61% 45%

By position

Starter picks correct by position, Week 9 Half PPR
Starter picksLMDExpert ConsensusPrevious-week results baseline
QB8/127/126/12
RB12/2412/2413/24
WR12/2412/247/24
TE5/125/124/12
Typical rank miss by position, Week 9 Half PPR
Typical missLMDExpert ConsensusPrevious-week results baseline
QB5.55.54
RB10.51010
WR7.51029
TE9.510.59

Where LMD differed from Expert Consensus

At each position, the players LMD or Expert Consensus ranked in its top 20 and the two placed at least 4 places apart. For each, which ranking was nearer the player's actual Week 9 finish.

Disagreements between LMD and Expert Consensus, Week 9
PlayersLMD nearerECR nearerLMD avg missECR avg miss
QB3124.33.0
RB103611.69.7
WR75113.016.2
TE43118.520.3
All24121012.212.5

Ranks and finishes are positional, Half PPR; the averages are positional places, over the players who played. 2 players did not play and are credited to neither. Expert Consensus ranks are graded in aggregate and are not listed player by player. One week is a small sample.

Hits and misses

Ranked → finished

Hits

Misses

Limitations

At 2 clubs the quarterback who threw the most passes was not on the board at all: Shedeur Sanders (CLE, QB5) and Carson Wentz (MIN, QB38).

Probability accuracy

Top-12 Brier score. The equal-chance baseline gives every player at a position the same probability.

LMD
0.076
Equal-chance baseline
0.097

Brier score measures how accurate probability forecasts are. 0 is perfect; lower is better.

Methodology & detailed stats

We graded the Week 9 board we published on November 5, 2026, the last one generated before the first game kicked off, against what happened. Nothing was regenerated, re-ranked or adjusted after the games, and the misses are listed the same way as the hits.

The comparison at the top of this page grades LMD, Expert Consensus and the previous-week results baseline on the same players. Every other figure grades LMD's whole board on its own.

Starter picks

A starter call is a player we ranked inside the starters a 12-team league fields at each position, not counting flex spots: 12 quarterbacks, 24 running backs, 24 wide receivers, 12 tight ends. It is a hit when he finished inside the same line at his position. A player we ranked as a starter who did not play counts as a miss, because the board's rankings already account for the chance a player sits.

37 of 72 players we ranked as starters finished as starters (51%).

Of the 72 players who actually finished as starters, we had ranked 37 inside the line (51%). That is the same count read the other way: we rank exactly as many starters as the league fields, and exactly that many finish there unless players tie.

6 players we ranked as starters recorded no statistic and count as misses. DeVonta Smith, Garrett Wilson and Mike Evans were ruled out in a status capture taken after the board went up, which a board published before the week cannot see: check the current board before lineups lock.

Week 9 starter calls by position, Half PPR
PositionStarter lineFinished as startersHit rateActual startersCapture rate
QBTop 128 of 1267%1267%
RBTop 2412 of 2450%2450%
WRTop 2412 of 2450%2450%
TETop 125 of 1242%1242%
All fourBy position37 of 7251%7251%

Hit rate: of the players we ranked as starters, the share who finished as starters. Capture rate: of the players who finished as starters, the share we had ranked as starters, including players we did not rank at all.

Start/sit calls

For each position, the pool is every player LMD ranked near the starter line (QB and TE ranked 7 to 18 and RB and WR ranked 13 to 36), and every pair in it is compared once: a call is right when the player ranked higher scored more. A player who did not play scored zero.

LMD put the higher scorer first in 675 of 1151 scored pairs (59%). Picking at random would be right half the time.

Week 9 start/sit calls on shared pairs, by position, Half PPR
PositionRanks comparedPlayersPairs scoredLMD rightLMD rate
QB7-18171368160%
RB13-363042723956%
WR13-363247128961%
TE7-18161176656%
All fourBy position95115167559%

1187 pairs in all. Left out for every ranking: 34 pairs whose players scored exactly the same and 0 pairs LMD ranked equally.

Rank misses

How many places each player finished from where we ranked him, for the players we ranked as starters who recorded a stat line. A receiver we ranked WR8 who finished WR14 is 6 places off.

Across 66 players, the average miss was 12.5 places and the median 9. A few large misses pull the average up; the median is the typical player.

Week 9 rank error for players ranked as starters who recorded a stat line, Half PPR
PositionPlayersAverage missMedian miss
QB126.95.5
RB2215.110.5
WR2014.47.5
TE129.99.5
All four6612.59

A player with no stat line has no finish, so he is left out here and counted as a miss in the starter calls above.

The same measure over the players ranked inside the top 24 at their position who recorded a stat line, as earlier reviews reported it. A receiver ranked WR8 who finished WR14 is a miss of 6 places.

Week 9 rank accuracy by position, top 24, Half PPR
PositionRanked top 24With a stat lineMedian missWithin 6Rank corr. (top 24)Rank corr. (whole board)
QB24226.550%0.400.56
RB242210.532%0.400.62
WR24207.550%0.410.63
TE242412.525%0.440.68
All four9688939%----

Rank correlation is Spearman's: 1 is the right order, 0 is no relationship. Inside the top 24 it is a hard test, because those players are close together; over the whole board it is an easier one, because it includes backups who were never near a start. It is not pooled across positions, which would correlate four different orderings.

Top 3, 12 and 24 picks

The same count at every finish line the board prints: of the players we ranked inside the top 3, 12 or 24 at their position, how many finished there, all four positions together. The chances printed beside each rank are graded as probabilities further down.

Week 9 Top 3, 12 and 24 calls, all positions, Half PPR
ThresholdFinished insideHit rateActual finishersCapture rate
Top 35 of 1242%1242%
Top 1225 of 4852%4852%
Top 2457 of 9659%9759%

Top 24 is a wide net at quarterback and tight end, where a 12-team league starts 12, so the starter calls above are the better read there.

Top 3 by position
PositionFinished insideHit rateActual finishersCapture rate
QB1 of 333%333%
RB1 of 333%333%
WR2 of 367%367%
TE1 of 333%333%
All four5 of 1242%1242%
Top 12 by position
PositionFinished insideHit rateActual finishersCapture rate
QB8 of 1267%1267%
RB7 of 1258%1258%
WR5 of 1242%1242%
TE5 of 1242%1242%
All four25 of 4852%4852%
Top 24 by position
PositionFinished insideHit rateActual finishersCapture rate
QB18 of 2475%2475%
RB12 of 2450%2450%
WR12 of 2450%2450%
TE15 of 2463%2560%
All four57 of 9659%9759%

Every hit and miss list

Hits

Ranked inside the starter line (Top 12 at QB and TE, Top 24 at RB and WR) and finished inside it, closest to the rank first.

  1. WR Puka NacuaLAR Ranked WR2 · WR2 · 28.0 pts · Top 24: 69%
  2. TE Isaiah LikelyNYG Ranked TE5 · TE5 · 13.8 pts · Top 12: 44%
  3. QB Dak PrescottDAL Ranked QB8 · QB8 · 19.5 pts · Top 12: 51%
  4. WR Tetairoa McMillanCAR Ranked WR14 · WR14 · 13.6 pts · Top 24: 43%
  5. WR Nico CollinsHOU Ranked WR16 · WR16 · 13.5 pts · Top 24: 42%

Misses: ranked as starters, finished outside

Ranked inside the starter line and finished outside it or recorded no statistic, the ones we gave the best chance first. Players ruled out in a later status capture are listed separately below.

  1. WR Jaxon Smith-NjigbaSEA Ranked WR1 · WR34 · 8.6 pts · Top 24: 71%
  2. RB D'Andre SwiftCHI Ranked RB6 · RB51 · 3.1 pts · Top 24: 68%
  3. RB Jonathan TaylorIND Ranked RB8 · RB31 · 6.9 pts · Top 24: 65%
  4. RB Kyren WilliamsLAR Ranked RB9 · RB29 · 7.6 pts · Top 24: 63%
  5. QB Josh AllenBUF Ranked QB3 · QB16 · 12.9 pts · Top 12: 57%

Misses: finished as starters, ranked outside

Ranked outside the starter line and finished inside it, the ones we gave the smallest chance first.

  1. WR Van JeffersonWAS Ranked WR153 · WR12 · 14.3 pts · Top 24: 1%
  2. RB Kaleb JohnsonGB Ranked RB75 · RB12 · 12.8 pts · Top 24: 3%
  3. RB Audric EstiméNO Ranked RB72 · RB9 · 14.2 pts · Top 24: 4%
  4. WR Kayshon BoutteHOU Ranked WR91 · WR5 · 26.5 pts · Top 24: 4%
  5. WR Jordan WatkinsSF Ranked WR92 · WR11 · 16.6 pts · Top 24: 4%

Ruled out after the board was published

Ranked inside the starter line, then ruled out in a status capture taken after the board went up. Listed apart from the misses because the status evidence the board was built from did not rule him out.

  1. WR DeVonta SmithPHI Ranked WR11 · Did not play (ruled out) · -- · Top 24: 44%
  2. WR Garrett WilsonNYJ Ranked WR17 · Did not play (ruled out) · -- · Top 24: 41%
  3. WR Mike EvansSF Ranked WR22 · Did not play (ruled out) · -- · Top 24: 38%

Finished as starters without being ranked

  • Shedeur Sanders (CLE): QB5, 22.7 pts
  • Pat Bryant (DEN): WR14, 13.6 pts
  • Keleki Latu (BUF): TE10, 9.0 pts

Probability detail

Beside each rank the board prints a chance of finishing in the top 3, 12 and 24 at his position. If those chances are right, a group of players each given 60% should get there about 60% of the time, and the total number of finishers should land near the sum of the chances. They are graded as probabilities, not as yes-or-no calls at 50%.

Week 9 finish probabilities, all 400 ranked players
ThresholdExpected finishersActualTypical rangeBrierSame % for allRank as yes/no
Top 312.0125-180.0250.0290.035
Top 1247.74636-590.0760.0970.110
Top 2494.39381-1080.1190.1570.188

Typical range is the expected count plus or minus two standard deviations of what the chances imply. Brier is the mean squared gap between each chance and what happened; lower is better. "Same % for all" gives every player at a position the same chance, and "rank as yes/no" says 100% inside the threshold and 0% outside: two simple forecasts the chances should beat. Groups under 10 players are shown faded: too few to read.

  • The number of Top 3, Top 12 and Top 24 finishes landed inside the range the percentages implied (12 against 12.0, 46 against 47.7 and 93 against 94.3).
  • At every threshold the percentages scored better than reading the rank as a yes-or-no call, so the odds columns said something the rank alone did not.
  • One position at a time, the percentages lost to a simple forecast at Top 3 WR (0.014 against 0.012 for the rank as yes or no). The pooled figures above do not show it.
  • Players given a 0-5% chance of a Top 12 finish got there 3% of the time against 1% predicted. That is outside the range chance allows for a group of 218.
  • Of the 49 players given a 30-50% chance of a Top 24 finish, 31% got there. A percentage on the board is a rate across many players like him, not a call on one.
  • 123 of the 400 ranked players recorded no statistic. Their chances are part of every percentage above, which is why the whole board is graded rather than only the players who played.
  • Of the Top 24 finishes the board expected, players who recorded no statistic were given 2.9 of 24 at running back (28 players), 4.3 of 24 at wide receiver (58 players) and 3.9 of 23 at tight end (34 players). Chances spread onto players who did not take the field are chances the starters' percentages did not get, so read a small percentage beside a backup's name with that in mind.
Week 9 finish probabilities by position
ThresholdExpected finishersActualBrierSame % for allRank as yes/no
Top 3 QB3.030.0820.0870.129
Top 3 RB3.030.0240.0290.039
Top 3 WR3.030.0140.0170.012
Top 3 TE3.030.0260.0310.042
Top 12 QB11.8110.1730.2300.226
Top 12 RB12.0120.0790.1040.098
Top 12 WR12.0120.0550.0650.081
Top 12 TE11.9110.0790.1020.137
Top 24 QB23.4220.1760.2100.323
Top 24 RB24.0240.1460.1800.235
Top 24 WR24.0230.0900.1160.134
Top 24 TE23.0240.1240.1890.190
Top 3: players grouped by the chance the board gave them
Board's chancePlayersAverage chanceActually finished there95% range
0-5%3061%0%0%-2%
5-15%789%8%4%-16%
15-30%1620%31%14%-56%
Top 12: players grouped by the chance the board gave them
Board's chancePlayersAverage chanceActually finished there95% range
0-5%2181%3%2%-6%
5-15%649%5%2%-13%
15-30%5923%14%7%-25%
30-50%4739%40%28%-55%
50-70%1256%75%47%-91%
Top 24: players grouped by the chance the board gave them
Board's chancePlayersAverage chanceActually finished there95% range
0-5%1172%4%2%-10%
5-15%1019%8%4%-15%
15-30%5822%24%15%-37%
30-50%4939%31%20%-45%
50-70%4258%60%44%-73%
70-85%2379%74%54%-87%
85-100%1087%90%60%-98%

Were firmer calls more reliable?

No confidence rating was published with the Week 9 board, so there is none to grade. What the board did publish is how one-sided each player's chance was. Here the players ranked in the top 24 at each position are grouped by their Top 12 chance: the further from an even split, the firmer the call. The median rank miss counts only those who recorded a stat line.

Week 9 Top 12 calls by how one-sided they were, players ranked top 24 at their position
Top 12 chancePlayersExpected on the favoured sideActually on itMedian rank miss
35-65%4557%58%7
15-35% or 65-85%5173%80%12.5
Under 15% or over 85%0------

In every group large enough to read, the share landing on the favoured side was within the range its percentages implied. Firmer calls missed by more places (median 12.5 against 7), which in one week is not evidence either way.

Top finish picks against the model input

The top finish picks, graded the same way for LMD and for the outside projection it uses as one input. Because the projection feeds the board, this is a check on the model, not a comparison with an independent ranking.

Top finish picks: LMD against one of its inputs, Week 9 Half PPR
MeasureLMDOutside projection (model input)
Top 3 picks correct5 of 12 (42%)4 of 12 (33%)
Top 12 picks correct25 of 48 (52%)24 of 48 (50%)
Top 24 picks correct57 of 96 (59%)59 of 96 (61%)

Other scoring formats

Week 9 headline figures in each scoring format
ScoringStarter callsStart/sit callsMedian rank error (starters)Top 12 Brier
Standard47%57%90.081
Half PPR51%59%90.076
Full PPR54%59%80.076

How this review was graded

The comparison. LMD, Expert Consensus and the previous-week results baseline are graded on the same players, finishes and start/sit pairs, by the same calculations as the rest of this page. No game kicked off before the Expert Consensus lists, so every player is graded. Every rank is the one the list printed. The start/sit pool is every player any of the three put near the starter line; a pair is scored for all three or for none, and a player a list did not rank counts as ranked below everyone it did. 2,080 of 2,237 pairs were scored: 66 pairs scored the same, and 91 pairs were tied on at least one list.

Expert Consensus. The Half PPR tier lists for QB, RB, WR and TE, published November 5, 14:01 UTC. A player's rank is his place in the list, across tiers, in the last list published no later than LMD's board was generated. That list can be hours older than the board, so it may not reflect news LMD's board had. 151 listed players were matched to our catalog by name and position; all of them were matched.

Previous-week results baseline. Each position ranked by the points players actually scored in Week 8, Half PPR, from the same statistics as the rest of this page. Nothing is adjusted for injuries, matchups or roles. A player with no stat line that week is not on the list, and players who scored the same share a rank.

The board. Four boards were archived for Week 9. This review grades the final pre-kickoff v1.5.2 board. It was generated 7.1 hours before the first kickoff (November 6, 01:15 UTC), and it is the board readers saw going into the week. The November 8 refresh was generated after games had started and is not graded here.

The population. All 400 players the board ranked at QB, RB, WR and TE. A finish is counted over every player in the league who recorded a statistic (340 stat lines, including 63 players the board did not rank), priced with the same Half PPR scoring the board projected. Players who tie share the better place.

Starter calls. The starter line is Top 12 at quarterback and tight end and Top 24 at running back and receiver. The hit rate counts the players ranked inside it who finished inside it; the capture rate counts the players who finished inside it, ranked by us or not, whom we had ranked inside it. Top 3, 12 and 24 use the same arithmetic.

Start/sit calls. The pool is every player LMD ranked inside half a starter line either side of it (QB and TE ranked 7 to 18 and RB and WR ranked 13 to 36), and every pair in it is formed once. A pair is scored only when the two players' points differ and LMD put them in a strict order. The band is set by the starter line, not chosen after the games.

Rank error. The number of places between a player's published positional rank and his finish, over the players ranked inside the starter line who recorded a stat line. Earlier reviews reported it over the top 24 at every position, and that table is kept under the rank error section.

Players who did not play. 123 ranked players recorded no statistic. 25 were ruled out in a status capture taken after the board was published (November 8, 11:57 UTC) and 98 had no ruling; 2 of those were quarterbacks. A player we ranked as a starter who did not play is a missed starter call, and scores zero in a start/sit comparison. Players who did not play are left out of the rank error, which needs a finish, and counted as misses in the probability checks, because the board's rankings and percentages already include the chance a player sits.

What is not adjusted. Nothing is corrected for in-game injuries, game script or garbage time: a player who left early is graded on what he scored. Player pages chart the last board before each player's own kickoff, so for later games their Week 9 projection can come from a newer board than this one.

Sample size. This is one week. A few players' afternoons move every figure on this page, so read it as one data point rather than a verdict, and nothing here has been used to retune the model.

Sources and evidence

  • Model rankings-v1.5.2, configuration 91a0267e0790c386, board of 2026-11-05 generated November 5, 18:08 UTC.
  • Archived board (Half PPR): rankings/2026/week-09/artifacts/rankings-v1.5.2/2026-11-05/weekly-half.json, SHA-256 be9786b0d7e8d0b2c671e1b4759af1b0a5d5df3e608539a09ab543c554779e5f.
  • Results: nflverse weekly player statistics, published November 10, 17:04 UTC (CC BY 4.0). 4 stat lines could not be matched to our player catalog and still count toward finishes.
  • Rulings: balldontlie status capture of November 8, 11:57 UTC, used only to label players who did not play.
  • Outside projection (model input): captured November 5, 18:06 UTC, 315 rows (2 not matched to our catalog, none inside a graded depth), SHA-256 061cd8dc33ac5143483bcbdd2e77fcf11f7a24737ec794d7ca93f797182e98f0.
  • Expert Consensus: the Half PPR lists published November 5, 14:01 UTC, 151 rows. Comparison inputs SHA-256 567765b9187262bfcffb172f2cfeab3a3bf13bba59ef1acaa85c9cc5d84785d9.
  • Per-player evaluation SHA-256 4093733d5cb1fc118ff86fb8649859a555ef5851ad889e81011c08e041fcd08b.

See this week's rankingsPrevious: 2026 Week 8 reviewNext: 2026 Week 10 review

Finding LMD useful? Support the project